The promise of a college degree has long been tied to the prospect of a higher earning potential. While this holds true on average, the landscape is more nuanced than ever before. For students investing significant time and money into their education, it's crucial to understand that not all bachelor's degrees are created equal in today's job market. Some fields, once considered stable career paths, are now experiencing a decline in inflation-adjusted starting salaries for new graduates.
This article provides a data-driven look at this trend, exploring which majors are affected, the reasons behind the decline, and—most importantly—the strategies you can employ to maximize your earning potential regardless of your chosen field.
Understanding the Trend: Why Some Majors Face Declining Salaries
A decline in starting salaries for a specific major isn't a random event. It's the result of powerful economic and industrial forces. The primary reason for this phenomenon is a mismatch between the supply of graduates in a particular field and the market's demand for their skills.
Key drivers include:
- Supply and Demand: Some fields produce more graduates than there are entry-level positions, giving employers leverage to offer lower starting wages.
- Technological Disruption & Automation: Technology can automate or devalue certain entry-level tasks, particularly in fields like data entry, basic research, and some forms of media production.
- Shifting Industry Priorities: Industries are rapidly evolving. The demand for skills in data science, software development, and specialized healthcare is growing, while demand in other, more traditional sectors may be stagnating or shrinking.
- Inflation: This is a critical factor. Even if a nominal salary for a major increases by 2% year-over-year, if inflation is at 4%, the *real* purchasing power of that salary has actually decreased. Many recent analyses focus on these "real wage" declines.
Examples of Majors with Recent Salary Declines
It's important to note that a "declining" salary trend does not mean graduates are unemployable or destined for low wages. It simply indicates that the entry-level market is more competitive and starting offers may not have the same purchasing power they once did.
According to analysis from sources like the Federal Reserve Bank of New York and the National Association of Colleges and Employers (NACE), several fields have seen stagnant or declining real starting wages in recent years.
- Mass Media & Journalism: The disruption of traditional media has led to a highly competitive market. While NACE's Winter 2023 Salary Survey reports an average starting salary of around $51,675 for communications graduates, this figure has struggled to keep pace with inflation. The job market is tight, with many entry-level roles in smaller markets or in digital media startups that offer lower pay.
- Liberal Arts & Humanities (e.g., History, Philosophy, English): These majors have historically had lower starting salaries. The Federal Reserve Bank of New York's data often shows these fields near the bottom for median early-career wages (around $40,000 - $45,000). The challenge is not a lack of skills, but the need to clearly translate skills like critical thinking and writing into tangible value for a specific business role.
- Fine Arts (e.g., Drama, Music, Fine Art): Similar to liberal arts, fine arts majors often face a difficult entry-level market. Payscale's College Salary Report consistently shows these majors with lower starting salaries, often below $45,000, as graduates pursue passion-driven roles in non-profits, galleries, and performance groups that are not always high-paying.
- Architecture: This field is highly sensitive to economic cycles. While the median pay for architects is high ($82,840 per year per the BLS), the starting salaries for recent graduates can dip during economic downturns when construction and development slow down.
Key Factors That Influence Salary (And How to Maximize Your Earnings)
A major's average starting salary is just a statistic. Your individual earnings will be determined by a combination of strategic choices. Here’s how you can take control of your career trajectory, even in a challenging field.
###
Level of Education
For many fields experiencing downward pressure on bachelor's degree salaries, an advanced degree can be a game-changer. A master's degree or Ph.D. can unlock specialized, higher-paying roles.
- Example: An English major might start at $45,000. However, with a Master's in Technical Communication or a Law Degree (J.D.), their earning potential skyrockets into the high five or six figures. A History B.A. may lead to an administrative role, but a Master's in Library Science (MLS) or Public Administration (MPA) opens doors to more stable, higher-paying government and academic positions.
###
Years of Experience
Starting salary is not career salary. This is the most critical point to remember. While a field may have a low starting median, its mid-career median can be substantially higher.
- Example: According to Payscale, a journalism major might start around $48,000 but can earn a mid-career median of over $85,000 as they move into editor, producer, or communications director roles. The initial years are about building a portfolio and gaining the experience that commands a higher salary later on.
###
Geographic Location
Where you work matters immensely. A job in a major metropolitan area like New York City or San Francisco will almost always pay more than the same job in a rural or suburban area to account for the high cost of living.
- Strategy: Use salary aggregator sites like Glassdoor and Salary.com to compare wages for your target role across different cities. Consider remote work opportunities, which can sometimes allow you to earn a salary benchmarked to a higher-cost area while living somewhere more affordable.
###
Company Type
The type and size of your employer are huge salary determinants. A graphic designer working for a Fortune 500 tech company will earn significantly more than one working for a local non-profit arts organization.
- Strategy: Don't limit your job search to the "obvious" industries for your major. An English major can be a highly-paid proposal writer for an engineering firm. A history major's research skills are valuable in a market intelligence role at a financial services company.
###
Area of Specialization
This is your single most powerful tool for bucking a trend. Within every broad major are in-demand specializations. The key is to pair your core degree with a lucrative, marketable skill.
- Humanities/Liberal Arts: Specialize in UX/UI Writing, SEO Content Strategy, Technical Writing, or Data-Driven Marketing. These roles leverage strong communication skills but apply them in high-growth, technical contexts.
- Communications/Journalism: Specialize in Public Relations for the tech or healthcare sector, Internal Corporate Communications, or Digital Analytics. These are stable, corporate functions that value strong storytellers.
- Fine Arts: Pair your creative skills with business acumen. Specialize in Digital Marketing, Brand Management, or User Interface (UI) Design. This allows you to apply your aesthetic sense in a commercial environment that pays well.
Job Outlook
The job outlook for these fields is often a mixed bag, which is precisely why specialization is so important.
For example, the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) projects a 3% decline in employment for reporters, correspondents, and broadcast news analysts from 2022 to 2032. However, it projects a 6% growth for Technical Writers and a 7% growth for Public Relations Specialists during the same period.
This shows that while one path (traditional journalism) is shrinking, related paths that utilize the same core skills are growing. The successful graduate will be the one who identifies and pivots toward these growth areas.
Conclusion: Your Major Is a Starting Point, Not a Destination
Seeing that your chosen major may have a declining starting salary can be disheartening, but it should not be a deterrent. Instead, it should be a call to action for strategic career planning. The data is clear: a bachelor's degree alone is no longer a guaranteed ticket.
Your success will be defined by your ability to adapt and add value. Here are the key takeaways:
1. Acknowledge the Trends: Be realistic about the entry-level market for your field.
2. Specialize Intelligently: Identify and acquire in-demand skills that complement your degree.
3. Gain Practical Experience: Internships, freelance work, and personal projects are non-negotiable for building a competitive resume.
4. Think Beyond the Obvious: Apply your skills in unexpected, high-growth industries.
5. Focus on the Long Term: Remember that your starting salary is just one data point in a long and rewarding career.
Your major gives you a foundation of knowledge and a unique way of thinking. By combining that foundation with strategic specialization and a proactive approach to your career, you can build a prosperous future in any field you choose.